After a short break that took us to New York to host European and Gulf leaders on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly, we're glad to be back with the latest Europe Gulf Alert.
The Mecca Agreement’s first test is a big one
The text of the Mecca Agreement signed in August by Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Turkey became public October 20, answering one of the big questions about the defense pact: Is it really a NATO-like collective-defense arrangement that treats an attack on one as an attack on all, as it was described? We now know that the Mecca Agreement does indeed have a clause like NATO’s Article 5. As the Iran-aligned Houthis ramp up attacks on Saudi oil facilities and airports, the next big question is how the agreement will operate in practice. So far Pakistan has sent troops in a defensive capacity; non-signatory Egypt may do so as well; and parliamentary debates are underway in Turkey. It’s “a major test” for the agreement, Jean-Loup Samaan says, as he and other experts join us to break down the big questions swirling around Europe and the Gulf.
THE LATEST
via REUTERS
Defense and security
Diversified—and delicate
The sixteen articles of the Mecca Joint Defence Agreement, Turkey’s new mutual-defense pact with Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, were submitted to the Turkish parliament for approval on Tuesday. The alliance links NATO’s second-largest military with nuclear-armed Pakistan and Gulf heavyweight Saudi Arabia. In addition to the collective-defense language, the agreement has a clause binding members for ten years, and no end date.
Expert take
Jean-Loup Samaan
Nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Middle East Security Initiative
“The Mecca Agreement may have emerged as a way for Saudi Arabia to diversify its security partnerships beyond the United States, but it already faces a major test with the Houthi attacks on the kingdom. As Riyadh seeks to rally allies in its campaign against the Yemeni group, Turkey and Pakistan must strike a balance between showing solidarity with their Saudi partner and getting drawn into a new escalation in Yemen.”
European natural gas prices have surged to their highest level in nearly four years, driven by escalating Middle East shipping disruptions and stored gas levels dipping to their lowest point ever ahead of winter. EU gas storage is only 74 percent full, well below the five-year average of 89 percent and short of the bloc’s 80 percent November target. Analysts warn Europe faces increased competition with Asia for liquefied natural gas cargoes and may be vulnerable to another price shock, particularly if winter is colder than expected.
Expert take
Ariel Ezrahi
Nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Middle East Programs
“Where the markets would factor in an anticipated end of the Strait of Hormuz and Bab el-Mandeb crises, despite low gas reserves, prices would typically stabilize. However, as the prices have surged, the markets are clearly not expecting an end to these crises anytime soon. This is not surprising considering the heightened tensions in the region and the plausible expectation that the conflict could flare up again rather than end any time soon. With Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu seeking to delay or dismiss the upcoming Israeli elections that he may well lose (an attack on Iran would be one way to delay) as well as the possibility that Iran may wish to disrupt the US midterm elections with a preemptive strike (to counter President Donald Trump’s recent threats), and continuous Houthi successes, events are not providing any indication that the crisis is ending any time soon.”
EU officials were quick to stand in solidarity with the Saudi government after the attack by Houthi rebels on King Khalid International Airport in Riyadh. Christophe Farnaud, the EU ambassador to Saudi Arabia, said, “There can be no justification for indiscriminate attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure.” EU chief Ursula von der Leyen said the attack was a “dangerous escalation” and that “attacks by Iran’s proxies are pushing the region into a spiral of violence.” Iran reportedly offered to mediate talks between Saudi Arabia and the Houthis, and Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s foreign minister, warned that a military approach from Saudi Arabia would only further complicate the situation.
Expert take
Jeffrey Lightfoot
Nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council's Scowcroft Center Transatlantic Security Initiative
“At a moment of growing geopolitical fragmentation, Gulf Cooperation Council officials will welcome the quick statements of solidarity and support from leading EU officials condemning the Houthi attacks on King Khalid International Airport and will see them as evidence that Europe recognizes the wider stakes it has in preserving freedom of maritime, civil aviation, and energy flows in the region. However, Gulf leaders will recognize the limits of practical support that the European Union can offer as a bloc during a time of crisis and will be more inclined to look for concrete pledges of support and even assistance from individual countries in Europe—particularly France and the UK, which have significant military linkages to the region and hold permanent seats on the UN Security Council.”
The Middle East conflict will likely push many Gulf countries into economic contraction this year, but 2027 may bring a stronger rebound than previously expected, according to the International Monetary Fund’s latest World Economic Outlook. The IMF forecasts an expected growth of 6.3 percent across the Gulf, assuming that the Strait of Hormuz reopens, with Bahrain, Kuwait, Iraq, and Qatar most affected by the conflict, while Saudi Arabia will experience less contraction due to greater diversification of its energy export routes. The IMF also predicted that commodity importers in the region will remain relatively resilient to trade shocks.
Launched in September 2025, the Europe Gulf Forum is a platform bringing together the highest level of political and business leadership in Europe and the Gulf to advance greater strategic and economic engagement between the two regions.